The closely watched case involved the online shopping site newegg inc, which specializes in computer products, and software company soverain software llc, which had accused newegg of. Soverain software llc page 2 close of the evidence, the district court determined that newegg s obviousness challenge to soverain s patents was so deficient that the issue should not even go. Newegg disclosed in its ipo registration filing that its currently being sued for patent infringement by soverain software llc. Whether the federal circuits effective redefinition of obviousness as a pure question of law, allowing it to resolve disputed factual questions in the first. Soverain s brief on this appeal mentioned that claim 35 was in suit, but did not discuss the limitation in that claim or other soverain software v. Internet patent owner loses supreme court bid to revive suit. Newegg crushes patent troll in online shopping cart suit pcmag. Jan 20, 2014 does fighting back work, or is the patent system simply broken. On january 30, justice elena kagan attended the new york state bar associations annual gala, where she received the associations gold medal for distinguished service in the law and held a discussion with professor john barrett of st.
On appeal, the federal circuit reversed the district courts judgment, holding that issue preclusion applied in light of its previous decision in soverain software llc v. Newegg declined to pay, stating that its system is materially different and that the patents are invalid if given the scope asserted by soverain. Whether the federal circuits effective redefinition of obviousness as a pure question of law, allowing it to resolve disputed factual questions in the first instance on appeal, violates the seventh amendment and th. New and useful january 31, 20 january 29, 20 in soverain software llc v. Jan 25, 20 on january 22, 20, in soverain software llc v. Sep 28, 2009 newegg disclosed in its ipo registration filing that its currently being sued for patent infringement by soverain software llc. I started with wikipedias article on soverain software. Soverain software llc was a chicagobased company which owned patents for its ecommerce technology products. The court received briefs from each of soverain and newegg on june 24, 20, and responses on july 9, 20. Sealed motion emergency opposed motion to disqualify jones day filed by newegg inc. Computer parts, pc components, laptop computers, led.
Soverain software llc was a chicagobased company which owned patents for its. Internet patent owner loses high court bid to revive suit. Soverain software, a nonpracticing entity that gained media attention for suing newegg and other online retailers over shopping cart patents. The district courts removal of the legal question of obviousness from the jury did not violate the right to a jury trial. Im a big wikipedia fan, but articles about littleknown companies run the risk of getting more attention from the companys friends than. Court of appeals for the federal circuit newman, prost, reyna reversedinpart and vacatedinpart the district courts judgment that newegg infringed u. The district court, criticizing neweggs evidence on the issue of obviousness, removed that issue from the jury and decided it as a matter of law. Jan, 2014 the closely watched case involved the online shopping site newegg inc, which specializes in computer products, and software company soverain software llc, which had accused newegg of infringing. Newegg when i saw someone ask if soverain software was a patent troll. While the court will likely hear the remaining cases, which deal. Jan 22, 20 soverain software llc brought this patent infringement suit against newegg inc. Initially newegg was found to have infringed the patents in suit and soverain. Infamous patent troll soverain software targets apple products and.
Fong, pillsbury winthrop shaw pittman, llp, of houston, texas. Jan 23, 20 on january 22, 20, in soverain software llc v. District court for the eastern district of texas, tyler division entered final judgment in the case soverain software llc v. Llc and may not be used by third parties without explicit permission. Parties, docket activity and news coverage of federal case soverain software llc v. Does fighting back work, or is the patent system simply broken. We confirmed that claim 34 is representative of the shopping cart claims, including claim 35, and concluded that dependent claim 35 is invalid on the ground of obviousness. Soverain software llc brought this patent infringement suit against newegg inc. Sep 04, 20 earlier today the united states court of appeals for the federal circuit issued it latest decision in soverain software llc v. Newegg wins victory against shopping cart patent holder san.
The district court directed its substantive analysis to limitations in claim 34. Soverain filed suit in late 2007, newegg said, adding that if an. There, we held invalid as obvious claims 34 and 51 of the 314 patent and claims 17, 41, and 61 of the 492 patent. Newegg obtains successful outcome in patent infringement lawsuit 5042010 press release. Anyone who visited soverain softwares website could be forgiven for believing its a real company. Soverain software llc sued newegg and several other online retailers in 2010 for infringing upon three patents related to the shopping carts. Soverain ruling threatens patent system, high court told.
I first clued into this case in early september 20, when the united states court of appeals for the federal circuit had just issued it latest decision in soverain software llc v. Supreme court refuses to hear internet shopping patent case. The record showed that the software was abandoned by almost all of its initial licenses. Soverain software llc provides ecommerce software and services for enterprises, focusing on the publishing, news syndicate and digital content industries, and its flagship product transact has. High court wont eye obviousness in newegg patent case. Newegg also pointed out that licenses were taken to avoid the costs of litigation, and not to use the system. Earlier today the united states court of appeals for the federal circuit issued it latest decision in soverain software llc v. Get free access to the complete judgment in soverain software llc v. Sep 30, 20 soverain software llc page 2 close of the evidence, the district court determined that neweggs obviousness challenge to soverains patents was so deficient that the issue should not even go. Soverain ruling threatens patent system, high court told law360. Soverain software v newegg obviousness january 22, 20. After the district courts judgment, this court decided soverain software llc v. Although both sides had presented witnesses and evidence on the question of obviousness, the district courts removal of the legal question from the jury did not violate the right to jury trial. How newegg crushed the shopping cart patent and saved online.
Is this the beginning of the end for patent trolls. Does fighting back work, or is the patent system simply. United states court of appeals for the federal circuit. Mar 24, 2015 after the district courts judgment, this court decided soverain software llc v. I was reading about the us supreme court declining to hear soverain v. City of industry, ca on september 10, 2010, newegg inc. Supreme court on monday to reverse a federal circuit decision invalidating a soverain software llc ecommerce patent asserted against newegg. Court of appeals for the federal circuit newman, prost, reyna reversedinpart and vacatedinpart the district courts. Online retailer newegg scored a major victory against a wellknown patent.
301 551 630 580 121 208 892 1347 868 1317 783 1358 440 1096 1160 1471 238 1327 824 1449 1214 1309 155 924 87 10 1449 971 762 450 622 1154 676 628 275 912 207 1478 1434 163 219